Territorial disputes of India and Nepal

Territorial Boundaries of Nepal and India

The territorial boundary between India and Nepal begins at a western tripoint with China, specifically near the Limpiyadhura area. This trijunction represents a critical geographical point where the borders of three nations intersect, highlighting the strategic importance of this region. From the Limpiyadhura, the border extends to the southwest, weaving through the dramatic landscapes of the Himalayas, which are known not only for their natural beauty but also for their geopolitical significance. The border further descends through the Sivalik Hills, characterized by rolling hills and dense forests, and into the expansive Gangetic plain, a densely populated area that is vital for agriculture and commerce.

As the boundary continues its journey south-westward, it initially follows an overland route before utilizing the Mahakali River, which serves as a natural demarcation line. The river plays a crucial role in the local ecosystem and supports the livelihoods of communities living along its banks. Approaching the vicinity of Majhola, the border veers to the southeast direction, continuing to traverse varied terrain. This segment of the border is particularly complex, as it occasionally makes use of alternative geographical features such as rivers and hill crests to define its path.

Eventually, north-west of Islampur, the border shifts direction, turning northeast and maintaining its overland trajectory towards the eastern tripoint with China. This section of the border is strategically significant, encompassing key transport routes and access points that link India, Nepal, and China. The region is not only crucial for national security but also facilitates trade and cultural exchanges among the bordering nations. Maintaining clarity and resolving any potential disputes in these border areas is vital for fostering peaceful relations and ensuring cooperative governance between India and Nepal, which share deep historical, cultural, and economic ties.

Historical Context

The Indo-Nepal border region has a rich history, shaped by various dynasties and kingdoms over the centuries. Its modern configuration began to take form during British colonial rule in India, which commenced in the 17th century. The late 18th century marked a crucial turning point in this historical landscape, as the Kingdom of Nepal pursued territorial expansion. This expansion led to conflict with the British Empire, culminating in the Anglo-Nepalese War from 1814 to 1816. The war concluded with Nepal’s defeat, and the Treaty of Sugauli mandated Nepal to cede significant territories to the British, laying the groundwork for the contemporary India-Nepal border.

After the treaty, the British identified the Terai region as challenging to govern and, in a strategic move in 1816, they returned portions of this fertile land back to Nepal. This act reflected both a tactical withdrawal and recognition of the socio-economic significance of the Terai for Nepal. The delineation of the border during colonial times set the stage for future relations between the two nations, a relationship that would evolve dramatically as geopolitical landscapes shifted in the 20th century.

Post-Independence Relations

Upon gaining independence from British rule in 1947, India sought to establish amicable relationships with its neighbors, including Nepal. In 1950, India and Nepal confirmed their friendly ties by signing a treaty of peace and friendship, which underscored mutual respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity. Despite these positive intentions, disputes over certain border areas have persisted. The relations between the two countries have generally been cordial, marked by shared cultural, economic, and familial connections, particularly among communities living adjacent to the border.

However, tensions have periodically surfaced, notably during instances of political turmoil, which have sometimes led to border blockades. Significant events, such as the blockades in 1987 and 2015, highlighted how domestic tensions can reverberate across borders, impacting trade and movement. These incidents often reveal the fragility of the bilateral relationship, despite a longstanding sense of kinship among border communities.

Kinship and Cultural Ties

Communities living in close proximity to the Indo-Nepal border historically maintain deep-rooted ties that transcend national boundaries. These connections are not only familial but also cultural and economic, manifested in shared traditions, languages, and resource access. The Mahakali Valley, a notable section of the western Indo-Nepal border, exemplifies the intertwining of lives and livelihoods across this international divide. Families often have relatives on both sides of the border, which underscores the complexity of territorial disputes amid deeply embedded kinship networks.

The shared history has fostered a sense of belonging and mutual dependency between the people of both nations, emphasizing that while geopolitical disputes may arise, the human connections remain strong. As both India and Nepal navigate their respective national identities, these communities serve as a reminder of the interconnectedness that can exist despite political divisions, highlighting the importance of dialogue and cooperation in resolving boundary issues while preserving the social fabric that binds them.

Border Disputes Overview

The territorial conflicts between India and Nepal are primarily centered around two regions: Kalapani and Susta. Kalapani, which encompasses approximately 35 square kilometers (14 square miles), is strategically located at the trijunction of India, Nepal, and China in the northwestern part of Nepal. This area has been a focal point of contention, with both nations citing historical references and geographical markers to assert their claims.

Susta, the second area in dispute, is situated in southern Nepal and varies in size from 20 square kilometers (7.7 square miles) to as much as 140 square kilometers (54 square miles) depending on the territorial delineations in question. The Ganges River, which flows through this region, has seen significant changes in its course over the years, complicating the borders and intensifying the disputes. The shifting riverbanks have led to claims of land loss for both India and Nepal, further exacerbating tensions.

Important Historical Context

The roots of these disputes can be traced back to historical treaties, especially the Sugauli Treaty of 1815-1816, which defined the borders between British India and the Kingdom of Nepal. However, subsequent interpretations of the treaty have led to different views on the rightful ownership of these territories. In recent years, both countries have sought to clarify their positions, citing various legal documents, maps, and cultural ties to the land, leading to a rise in nationalistic sentiments on both sides.

Diplomatic Efforts and Recent Developments

The tensions over these border disputes have required diplomatic negotiations, though progress has often been slow and contentious. In 2019, Nepal released a new political map that included Kalapani, Susta, and other disputed territories, a move that escalated tensions and underscored the complexity of the issue. India rejected this unilateral claim, stating that existing treaties and agreements should guide border delineation.

With both nations valuing their territorial integrity and identity, the resolution of these disputes remains a challenge. Dialogue between the two governments continues, but historical grievances and national pride often complicate the process. Achieving mutual understanding and agreement will be crucial in maintaining peaceful relations and stability in the region, especially as both countries navigate the geopolitical dynamics involving neighboring China.

Integrated Check Posts Overview

Integrated Check Posts (ICPs) are crucial facilities established by India to streamline customs and immigration processes at border crossings with neighboring countries, particularly Nepal. These posts not only serve Indian citizens and authorized travelers but also facilitate the entry and exit of third-country nationals, enhancing regional connectivity and security. Various ICPs have been set up along the extensive Indo-Nepal border from west to east, underscoring India's commitment to improving its border management infrastructure.

Uttarakhand and Uttar Pradesh ICPs

In Uttarakhand, the ICP located at Banbasa in the Champawat district connects to Dodhara Chandani in Nepal's Kanchanpur District. This post was established in 2023, marking a significant enhancement in cross-border movement and trade. Plans are in place for an additional crossing at Pithoragarh-Dasharathchanda to further bolster regional trade and people-to-people connections.

Moving to Uttar Pradesh, two important ICPs have been established recently: Rupaidiha in Bahraich district, which connects to Nepalganj in Banke District, and Sonauli in Maharajganj district, linking to Belahia in Siddharthanagar District. Both of these posts opened in 2022 and 2023 respectively, signifying a strategic move to facilitate smoother immigration and customs operations. These crossings are vital for boosting trade and tourism in the region.

Bihar's Key Crossings

Bihar plays an essential role in Indo-Nepal trade with several established ICPs. The Raxaul-Birgunj crossing, known as the 'Gateway of Nepal,' has seen its ICP operational since 2018. This facility has become one of the busiest crossings due to its strategic importance. Additionally, the Bhitthamore-Malibara crossing and the Jogbani-Biratnagar linkage further enhance the trade corridor between the two nations, with the latter's ICP established in 2020. Furthermore, there are plans for additional crossings, including Bairia-Gauriganj and Salgori-Kechna, indicating an ongoing effort to strengthen connectivity.

Integrated Cross-Border Facilities in West Bengal

In West Bengal, the Panitanki corridor in Darjeeling district connects to Kakarbhitta in Nepal, enhancing the corridor's operational capacity. The planned expansions, such as Panitanki (Naxalbari)-Birtamode and Sukhia Pokhri-Pashupatinagar, aim to improve trade and travel, fostering greater cultural and economic interactions between India and Nepal. The development of these ICPs is indicative of the growing bilateral ties and the focus on improving border infrastructure for mutual benefit.

The establishment and planned development of Integrated Check Posts along the India-Nepal border reflect strategic initiatives aimed at enhancing trade, security, and connectivity. By systematically bolstering these facilities, both nations are positioned to reap the benefits of a more connected and cooperative relationship.

Customs Crossings

The India-Nepal border is quite unique in its lack of physical barriers, leading to a variety of both official and unofficial customs crossings along this long and historically intertwined boundary. These crossings offer valuable economic and cultural interactions between the two neighboring countries. Smaller, officially recognized border crossings, known as Chhoti Bhansar in the Nepali language, facilitate trade and movement through several key points that play essential roles in the local economies.

In the far west, crossing into Nepal from the Indian state of Uttarakhand occurs mainly at Jhulaghat in Pithoragarh district, which connects to Mahakali in Baitadi District, Nepal. Moving eastward into Uttar Pradesh, the crossings become even more numerous. For example, Gauriphanta in Lakhimpur Kheri district links to Dhangadi, while Murtiha offers access to Gulariya in Bardiya. Other significant connections include Tal Baghaura and Tulsipur, which connect various districts on both sides, allowing not only for trade but also for the movement of people and culture.

Bihar also hosts several critical customs crossings. The Bhitthamore crossing in Sitamarhi leads to Jaleshwor in Mahottari District, Nepal, while the Valmiki Nagar crossing in West Champaran connects to Thori in Parsa District, benefiting local economies through agricultural and wholesale markets. Other crossings like Bairgania, Sonbarsa, and Jainagar further boost trade relations between the two nations. It should be noted that many of these crossings allow agricultural products, textiles, and handicrafts to flow freely between India and Nepal, reinforcing economic ties.

In Madhubani district, crossings such as Pipraun and Laukaha further explore comprehensive routes to different Nepali districts, including Dhanusa and Siraha. Notably, Kunaolee, located in Supaul district, connects to Bhantabari-Haripur in Sunsari District via the Kosi barrage, showcasing how water infrastructure can facilitate border trade. Araria district's Amgachhi links to Rangeli in Morang District, Nepal, marking another important commercial route. In Kishanganj district, border points like Bahadurganj and Galgalia also contribute to the dynamic trade ecosystem.

Further east, in West Bengal, the Mirik crossing in Darjeeling district connects to Pashupatinagar in Ilam, Nepal, allowing for significant cultural exchange and tourism opportunities. These customs crossings not only provide economic benefits but also strengthen the cultural links between India and Nepal. As both countries share historical ties and a long-standing friendship, the numerous crossings contribute to maintaining and enhancing diplomatic relations, highlighting the importance of open borders in promoting mutual cooperation.

Cross-Border Railway Connectivity

India and Nepal have been working to enhance their cross-border railway connectivity with a variety of projects that either have been completed or are currently underway. As of now, eight railway lines are proposed or in various stages of development, underscoring the commitment to strengthen the transport linkages between the two nations. This developing infrastructure is integral to not only boosting trade and commerce but also in facilitating easier movement for people across the border, which may contribute to economic and cultural exchanges.

The Babaganj-Nepalganj line is fully operational, marking a successful connection between the two countries. This line serves as a vital link for passengers and goods, enhancing regional trade potential. Other lines in the pipeline demonstrate the optimism and strategic intent behind deepening bilateral relations. Notably, the Barhani-Kathmandu line and the Barhani-Kapilvastu line are both under planning. These projects hold significant promise for linking the capital of Nepal, Kathmandu, to the intricate rail network of India, thereby enabling smoother transit and commerce.

Several other rail lines are also in various developmental stages. The Nautanwa-Bhairwa line and the Raxaul-Kathmandu line are among the other planned projects aimed at increasing connectivity between the two nations further. One of the more advanced projects is the Jaynagar-Bardibas railway line, which is mostly complete with 52 km finished out of a total 68 km, although the completion is contingent upon land acquisition concerns for the final phase.

The Jogbanu-Biratnagar railway line is similarly progressing, where 10.6 km have been constructed out of a total 18.6 km. With only an 8 km section remaining under construction, this project is poised to accelerate cross-border connective capacity once completed. Lastly, the planning stages for the Kakarbhitta-New Jalpaiguri railway line indicates the ongoing expansion of rail networks aimed at promoting synergy between the border regions of India and Nepal, thereby paving the way for enhanced trade and mobility that is essential in today's globalized economy.

Overall, these interconnected railway projects are not merely infrastructural feats; they represent a significant step toward regional integration and cooperation that could have transformative impacts on both countries. By improving transport links, India and Nepal aim to bolster their economic ties, improve access to services, and foster greater social connections that are vital in building a shared future.

Border Dynamics

The Nepal–India border is characterized by a long-standing cooperative relationship, making it one of the most peaceful borders in the world. The open-border policy allows Nepali and Indian nationals to cross back and forth without the need for passports or visas. This freedom of movement has facilitated not only cultural exchange but also significant economic activities, with tens of thousands of individuals crossing the border every day for purposes of tourism and trade. This interconnectedness is a testament to the deep historical, cultural, and familial ties that exist between the two nations.

On the security front, the Indian side of the border is primarily monitored by the Sashastra Seema Bal (SSB), which is supported by local police forces. Similarly, the Armed Police Force (APF) oversees security on the Nepali side, supplemented by the local branches of Nepal Police. These two agencies are crucial for maintaining order along the border and ensuring that the movement of people and goods is conducted lawfully and efficiently. Regular joint patrols conducted by SSB and APF highlight a spirit of collaboration and mutual trust between the two nations, enhancing the security framework of the region.

Local governance plays a vital role in border management. Regular meetings between Indian and Nepali district officials are organized to address security challenges and other cross-border issues. These meetings are typically attended by key figures such as District Magistrates, representatives from SSB, and customs chiefs from both sides, including the Chief District Officer (CDO) from India. Such dialogues foster transparency and cooperation, allowing officials to discuss matters such as smuggling, illegal immigration, and other security concerns while working together to implement effective solutions that benefit both countries. Moreover, the consistent interaction between local authorities helps strengthen bilateral ties and promotes a sense of community along the border areas.

Overall, the effective coordination between law enforcement agencies and the collaboration at various administrative levels underscore the importance of maintaining peace and security along the Nepal–India border. The model of open borders, coupled with strong local governance, not only benefits citizens of both nations but also serves as a positive example for other countries facing similar border management challenges.