India Myanmar Land Border Crossing Agreement And Connectivity Projects

India and Myanmar have solidified their bilateral relations with an agreement concerning land border crossing, building upon the existing Free Movement Regime (FMR). This regime grants specific rights to tribal communities, including Nagas, Singhpos, Kukis, and Mizos, who reside in the border areas and maintain trans-border connections. The FMR allows these tribes to travel up to 16 km across the border without visa restrictions. While India permits Myanmarese nationals to stay for 72 hours without a visa, Myanmar allows Indian nationals only a 24-hour stay.

Furthermore, India is actively engaged in developing four major connectivity projects within Myanmar. These include the Kaladan multi-modal corridor, the repair of 69 bridges on the Tamu-Kalewa road, the construction of the 120-km Kalewa-Yargyi corridor (a segment of the India-Myanmar-Thailand trilateral highway), and the Rhi-Tiddim road in the Chin state bordering Mizoram. In a parallel effort highlighting cultural ties, the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) has undertaken the restoration of the Ananda Temple in Bagan, Myanmar.

Deepening Ties: India and Myanmar's Enhanced Border Agreement and Connectivity Initiatives

The approval of the land border crossing agreement between India and Myanmar in 2018 represents a significant step in the ongoing evolution of their bilateral relationship. This agreement, building upon the existing Free Movement Regime (FMR), and the concurrent development of several key connectivity projects, underscores the strategic importance both nations place on strengthening their ties. The agreement addresses the specific needs and concerns of border communities, while the infrastructure projects aim to boost trade, tourism, and overall regional integration. Understanding the nuances of this agreement and the connectivity projects requires delving into the historical context, the key actors involved, the legal frameworks in place, and the broader implications for regional stability and economic development.

The Historical Underpinnings: A Shared Border and Complex Relations

India and Myanmar share a land border stretching approximately 1,643 kilometers, traversing diverse terrains and connecting several states in Northeast India (Arunachal Pradesh, Nagaland, Manipur, and Mizoram) with Myanmar’s Sagaing Region, Chin State, and Kachin State. This long and porous border has historically been a zone of interaction, trade, and cultural exchange. However, it has also been a region marked by challenges, including insurgency, drug trafficking, and cross-border crime.

The demarcation of the border during the colonial era, when both India and Myanmar were under British rule, created artificial divisions that often disregarded the traditional territories and linkages of indigenous communities. The British administration implemented policies that regulated movement across the border, but these policies were often inconsistent and difficult to enforce, leading to ongoing disputes and challenges.

Following their respective independence movements, India and Myanmar initially maintained cordial relations, rooted in shared anti-colonial sentiments and a commitment to non-alignment during the Cold War. India supported Myanmar’s transition to independence and provided assistance in various sectors. However, relations were strained following the 1962 military coup in Myanmar, which ushered in a period of isolation and authoritarian rule. India, as a democratic nation, found it increasingly difficult to engage with the military junta.

Despite the political differences, India maintained a pragmatic approach, recognizing the strategic importance of Myanmar as a neighbor and a gateway to Southeast Asia. During the 1990s, as India embarked on its "Look East" policy (later renamed "Act East"), Myanmar's significance grew even further. The Look East policy aimed to strengthen India's economic and strategic ties with Southeast Asian nations, and Myanmar became a crucial bridge in this endeavor.

The Free Movement Regime: Balancing Security and Traditional Ties

The Free Movement Regime (FMR) is a key element in the border management strategy between India and Myanmar. It is an arrangement that allows residents of border areas to cross the international boundary without visa restrictions. The primary objective of the FMR is to facilitate the traditional trans-border movement of tribal communities who have historically maintained close social, cultural, and economic ties across the border.

The FMR recognizes the unique circumstances of these communities, whose lives and livelihoods are intricately linked to areas on both sides of the border. These communities, including the Nagas, Singhpos, Kukis, and Mizos, often have relatives, friends, and business connections across the border. The FMR allows them to maintain these connections without the burden of visa requirements.

Under the FMR, residents of border areas are typically allowed to travel up to 16 kilometers (approximately 10 miles) across the border without a visa. They are required to carry identification documents, such as local resident certificates or voter ID cards, to verify their identity and residency. The FMR is intended to be a reciprocal arrangement, with both India and Myanmar granting similar rights to residents of their respective border areas.

However, the implementation of the FMR has been uneven, and there have been concerns about its potential misuse. Security agencies have expressed concerns that the FMR could be exploited by insurgents, drug traffickers, and other criminal elements to cross the border undetected. There have also been reports of illegal trade and smuggling taking place under the guise of the FMR.

The disparity in the allowed duration of stay further complicates the issue. While India allows Myanmarese nationals to stay for 72 hours without a visa under the FMR, Myanmar only permits Indian nationals a 24-hour stay. This asymmetry has been a point of contention, with some arguing that it puts Indian border residents at a disadvantage. Negotiations to harmonize these durations would be a beneficial step towards a more equitable and effective FMR.

Despite these challenges, the FMR remains an important instrument for managing the border between India and Myanmar. It is a recognition of the unique circumstances of border communities and their historical ties. The 2018 Land Border Crossing Agreement aims to strengthen the FMR by formalizing border crossing procedures and addressing some of the concerns related to security and illegal activities.

The Land Border Crossing Agreement: Formalizing and Regulating Movement

The Land Border Crossing Agreement, approved by both India and Myanmar in 2018, is a significant development in the management of the border. The agreement aims to formalize and regulate the movement of people across the border, supplementing the existing FMR and addressing some of its shortcomings.

The key provisions of the agreement likely include details regarding permitted crossing points, documentation requirements, and stay durations. The agreement is expected to streamline border crossing procedures, making it easier for legitimate travelers to cross the border while also strengthening security measures to prevent illegal activities.

The agreement is also expected to address the concerns related to the misuse of the FMR. By formalizing border crossing procedures and strengthening documentation requirements, the agreement aims to make it more difficult for insurgents, drug traffickers, and other criminal elements to exploit the FMR.

The agreement is a testament to the commitment of both India and Myanmar to strengthen their cooperation on border management. It is a recognition that effective border management is essential for maintaining peace and stability along the border, promoting trade and economic development, and addressing the needs of border communities.

Connectivity Projects: Building Bridges to Southeast Asia

In addition to the Land Border Crossing Agreement, India is actively involved in developing several major connectivity projects in Myanmar. These projects are aimed at improving infrastructure, boosting trade and tourism, and enhancing regional integration. These connectivity projects represent a tangible manifestation of India's Act East policy, aiming to transform the landlocked Northeast into a gateway for trade and investment with Southeast Asia.

• The Kaladan Multi-Modal Transit Transport Project: This ambitious project is designed to connect Kolkata (India) with Sittwe port in Myanmar by sea, and then link Sittwe to Mizoram (India) via river and road. The project involves the construction of a port in Sittwe, the dredging of the Kaladan River, and the construction of roads connecting Sittwe to Mizoram.

  The Kaladan project is of strategic importance to India as it provides an alternative route for trade and transport to Northeast India, bypassing the narrow "Chicken's Neck" corridor in West Bengal. The Chicken's Neck is a vulnerable stretch of land that connects Northeast India to the rest of the country, and it is susceptible to disruption due to natural disasters or security threats. The Kaladan project provides a more secure and reliable route for trade and transport to Northeast India.

  The project also has the potential to boost economic development in Mizoram and other parts of Northeast India. By improving connectivity, the project can facilitate trade and investment, create jobs, and improve the livelihoods of people in the region. However, the project has faced delays and challenges due to funding constraints, security concerns, and logistical difficulties.

• Repair of 69 Bridges on the Tamu-Kalewa Road: India is also involved in repairing 69 bridges on the Tamu-Kalewa road in Myanmar. This road is a crucial link in the India-Myanmar-Thailand Trilateral Highway, and the repair of the bridges is essential for ensuring the smooth flow of traffic. The poor condition of these bridges has long been a bottleneck, hindering trade and movement of people.

• The India-Myanmar-Thailand Trilateral Highway: This ambitious project aims to connect Moreh (India) to Mae Sot (Thailand) via Myanmar. The highway is expected to boost trade and tourism between India and Southeast Asia, promoting regional integration. The highway is a key component of India's Act East policy, and it is expected to play a significant role in promoting economic development in the region.

  The construction of the highway has faced several challenges, including security concerns, land acquisition issues, and logistical difficulties. However, significant progress has been made in recent years, and the highway is expected to be completed in the near future. The 120-km Kalewa-Yargyi section, currently under construction with Indian assistance, is a vital segment of this highway.

  Advertisement

• The Rhi-Tiddim Road: This road project involves the construction of a road connecting Rhi in Myanmar's Chin State to Tiddim, a town located near the border with Mizoram. This project aims to improve connectivity between the two regions and facilitate trade and people-to-people contact. This project is particularly important for the Chin people, an ethnic group residing in both Myanmar and Mizoram, enabling better communication and commerce between communities.

These connectivity projects represent a significant investment by India in Myanmar's infrastructure. They are expected to have a positive impact on trade, tourism, and economic development in both countries. However, the projects also face challenges, including funding constraints, security concerns, and logistical difficulties. Overcoming these challenges will be crucial for ensuring the successful completion of the projects.

The Archaeological Survey of India: Preserving Cultural Heritage

In addition to the connectivity projects, the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) has played a significant role in preserving cultural heritage in Myanmar. The ASI has undertaken the restoration of the Ananda Temple in Bagan, one of Myanmar's most important historical and religious sites.

The Ananda Temple is a Buddhist temple built in the 12th century. It is considered to be one of the finest examples of Mon architecture, and it is a popular tourist destination. The temple was damaged by an earthquake in 2016, and the ASI was invited by the Myanmar government to undertake its restoration.

The ASI's involvement in the restoration of the Ananda Temple is a testament to the strong cultural ties between India and Myanmar. It is also a recognition of India's expertise in the field of archaeology and conservation. The restoration project is expected to help preserve Myanmar's cultural heritage and promote tourism in the region.

Stakeholder Perspectives: Diverse Interests and Concerns

The India-Myanmar border region is characterized by a complex web of stakeholders, each with their own interests, concerns, and perspectives. Understanding these diverse perspectives is essential for developing effective policies and strategies for managing the border and promoting regional development.

• India: India's primary interest in the region is to strengthen its relations with Myanmar, promote regional connectivity, and address the needs of border communities. India seeks to enhance its strategic influence in the region, boost trade and investment, and counter China's growing presence. India has taken several actions to achieve these goals, including signing the Land Border Crossing Agreement, investing in connectivity projects, and providing humanitarian assistance.

• Myanmar: Myanmar seeks to benefit from Indian investment and cooperation, improve infrastructure, and promote economic development. Myanmar is also interested in maintaining stability along the border and addressing security concerns. Myanmar has signed the Land Border Crossing Agreement, cooperated on connectivity projects, and facilitated the restoration of cultural heritage sites.

• Tribal Communities: Tribal communities residing along the India-Myanmar border seek to maintain their traditional trans-border linkages and benefit from economic opportunities. They are interested in preserving their cultural identity, accessing markets and resources across the border, and improving their livelihoods. These communities utilize the Free Movement Regime to cross the border for trade, social interaction, and cultural exchange.

• Security Agencies: Security agencies in both India and Myanmar are concerned about the potential for cross-border crime, insurgency, and drug trafficking. They seek to strengthen border security measures and prevent illegal activities. These agencies advocate for stricter border controls and enhanced cooperation between the two countries.

• Economic Actors: Businesses and traders in both India and Myanmar are interested in promoting trade and investment in the region. They seek to reduce trade barriers, improve infrastructure, and facilitate cross-border commerce. These actors often support initiatives that promote regional connectivity and economic integration.

Broader Implications: Political, Economic, and Social Dimensions

The India-Myanmar Land Border Crossing Agreement and the connectivity projects have broad implications for the political, economic, and social landscape of the region.

• Political Implications: The agreement strengthens bilateral relations between India and Myanmar, enhancing India's influence in the region. It also promotes regional cooperation and integration, contributing to India's Act East policy. The enhanced relationship also serves as a counterweight to China's growing influence in the region.

• Diplomatic Implications: The agreement fosters goodwill and mutual understanding between India and Myanmar. It also demonstrates India's commitment to its neighbors and its willingness to cooperate on issues of mutual concern. This strengthens India's position as a responsible and reliable partner in the region.

• Legal Implications: The agreement provides a legal framework for border crossings, reducing the potential for disputes and illegal activities. It also clarifies the rights and obligations of individuals crossing the border. This contributes to a more stable and predictable legal environment.

• Security Implications: The agreement improves border management and security, helping to counter cross-border crime and insurgency. It also enhances cooperation between security agencies in the two countries. This contributes to a safer and more secure border region.

• Humanitarian Implications: The agreement addresses the needs of border communities and promotes their well-being. It also facilitates access to essential services and humanitarian assistance. This contributes to improved living conditions and reduced vulnerability for these communities.

• Economic Implications: The agreement boosts trade and investment, promoting economic development in both countries. It also creates new opportunities for businesses and entrepreneurs. This contributes to increased prosperity and job creation in the region.

  Advertisement

• Social Implications: The agreement facilitates cultural exchange and people-to-people contact, fostering greater understanding and goodwill. It also promotes social cohesion and reduces tensions between communities. This contributes to a more harmonious and inclusive society.

Connecting the Dots: Ongoing Issues, Historical Links, and Future Prospects

The India-Myanmar Land Border Crossing Agreement and the connectivity projects are closely linked to several ongoing issues, historical connections, and future prospects in the region.

• Related Ongoing Issues: These include India's Act East policy, regional connectivity initiatives in Southeast Asia, border management and security challenges in Northeast India, and the Rohingya refugee crisis in Myanmar and its impact on regional stability. These issues are interconnected and require a comprehensive and coordinated approach.

• Historical Connections: These include historical and cultural ties between India and Myanmar, colonial-era border demarcation and its impact on tribal communities, and India's support for Myanmar's transition to democracy. These historical connections shape the present-day relationship between the two countries and influence their approach to border management and regional cooperation.

• Future Outlook: The future outlook for the India-Myanmar border region is promising. Continued development of connectivity projects, further strengthening of bilateral relations, and potential for increased trade and investment are all positive signs. However, challenges remain, including security concerns, logistical difficulties, and the need to address the needs of border communities. Overcoming these challenges will be crucial for realizing the full potential of the region. Further negotiations to harmonize the visa-free stay durations for border residents would be a beneficial step towards a more equitable and effective FMR. Continued cooperation on border management, infrastructure development, and cultural exchange will be essential for building a prosperous and stable future for the India-Myanmar border region.