India Australia Relations Enhanced Strategic Partnership

In 2019, India and Australia significantly strengthened their bilateral relationship, elevating it to a Comprehensive Strategic Partnership during a virtual summit between their Prime Ministers. This upgrade included enhancing the '2+2' dialogue to the level of Foreign and Defence Ministers, mirroring similar strategic mechanisms India has with the USA and Japan.

The enhanced cooperation involved signing a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) on mining and processing critical and strategic minerals, along with a Mutual Logistics Support Agreement. A joint declaration also outlined a shared vision for maritime cooperation. India's focus on the Indo-Pacific region is further underscored by its Forum for India-Pacific Islands Cooperation (FIPIC) initiative, launched in 2014. An 'India Economic Strategy to 2035' was also formulated to strengthen long-term economic ties through economic collaboration, geostrategic engagement, and cultural exchange, identifying key sectors and Indian states for Australian investment. Furthermore, both countries are aiming to revive discussions on a Comprehensive Economic Cooperation Agreement (CECA) and collaborate in multilateral forums like the QUAD security dialogue, Indian Ocean Rim Association (IORA), ASEAN Regional Forum, G-20, and East Asia Summits.

The India-Australia Comprehensive Strategic Partnership: A Deep Dive

The elevation of India-Australia relations to a Comprehensive Strategic Partnership (CSP) in 2019 marked a significant milestone in the evolving dynamics of the Indo-Pacific region. This enhanced partnership, formalized during a virtual summit between the two nations’ Prime Ministers, signifies a deepening of ties across a spectrum of areas, including strategic, economic, and cultural spheres. It reflects a convergence of interests and a shared commitment to addressing regional and global challenges, particularly within the context of a changing geopolitical landscape.

Historical Context: From Distant Neighbors to Strategic Partners

The relationship between India and Australia has undergone a remarkable transformation over the decades. Initially, the connection was somewhat distant, shaped by historical factors, differing strategic orientations, and the shadow of the Cold War. However, the seeds of a stronger partnership were sown in the post-Cold War era, driven by shared democratic values, a growing recognition of mutual interests, and a desire to promote regional stability.

In the early years after India's independence, the two nations, both members of the Commonwealth, engaged primarily through multilateral forums and cultural exchanges. However, divergences in their foreign policy approaches, particularly during the Cold War, limited the scope for closer cooperation. India's non-aligned stance and its close ties with the Soviet Union contrasted with Australia's alignment with the Western bloc, led by the United States.

The end of the Cold War and the rise of globalization ushered in a new era in India-Australia relations. As both countries embraced economic liberalization and sought to expand their global engagement, they began to identify new areas of convergence. The growing importance of the Asia-Pacific region, and the rise of China as a major economic and military power, further incentivized closer cooperation between India and Australia.

The 1998 Indian nuclear tests, however, presented a temporary setback. Australia, a strong proponent of nuclear non-proliferation, imposed sanctions on India in response to the tests. However, this period of estrangement was relatively short-lived, as both countries recognized the need to move beyond the nuclear issue and focus on their shared strategic interests.

In the early 2000s, India and Australia began to actively cultivate a closer relationship. High-level visits, increased defense cooperation, and growing economic ties laid the foundation for a stronger partnership. The signing of a Memorandum of Understanding on Security Cooperation in 2006 marked a significant step forward in their strategic engagement.

The Indo-Pacific Pivot: A Catalyst for Enhanced Cooperation

The emergence of the Indo-Pacific as a key geopolitical concept has been a major catalyst for the deepening of India-Australia relations. The Indo-Pacific, encompassing the Indian Ocean and the western Pacific Ocean, is increasingly viewed as a single strategic arena, where the balance of power is shifting and new challenges are emerging.

Both India and Australia recognize the importance of maintaining a stable and rules-based order in the Indo-Pacific region, where freedom of navigation, respect for international law, and peaceful resolution of disputes are paramount. They share concerns about China's growing assertiveness in the region, particularly its territorial claims in the South China Sea and its increasing military presence in the Indian Ocean.

The Indo-Pacific concept provides a strategic framework for India and Australia to work together to promote their shared interests and address common challenges. It has led to increased cooperation in areas such as maritime security, defense, and counter-terrorism. Both countries are also working together to promote economic connectivity and sustainable development in the region.

Key Pillars of the Comprehensive Strategic Partnership

The Comprehensive Strategic Partnership between India and Australia is built on several key pillars, each contributing to the overall strength and depth of the relationship:

• Strategic Cooperation: The upgrade of the '2+2' dialogue to the level of Foreign and Defence Ministers is a significant development, reflecting the growing strategic trust and convergence between the two countries. This high-level dialogue provides a platform for discussing sensitive and strategic issues, coordinating policy responses, and enhancing defense cooperation. The Mutual Logistics Support Agreement (MLSA) further strengthens defense cooperation by allowing the armed forces of both countries to use each other's bases for logistics support during joint exercises, humanitarian assistance, and disaster relief operations. This enhances interoperability and facilitates closer coordination in responding to regional security challenges.

  Advertisement

• Economic Engagement: Trade and investment are key drivers of the India-Australia relationship. The two countries have set ambitious targets for increasing bilateral trade and investment in the coming years. The 'India Economic Strategy to 2035', commissioned by the Australian government, provides a roadmap for strengthening long-term economic ties. The strategy identifies ten key sectors and ten Indian states where Australia has competitive advantages, highlighting opportunities for increased collaboration in areas such as agriculture, education, energy, and infrastructure. The renewed commitment to re-engage in talks on a Comprehensive Economic Cooperation Agreement (CECA) is a positive step towards further liberalizing trade and investment flows between the two countries. A CECA would reduce or eliminate tariffs and other trade barriers, promoting increased trade and investment and creating new economic opportunities.

• Maritime Cooperation: As maritime nations with significant interests in the Indo-Pacific region, India and Australia share a strong commitment to maritime security and cooperation. The joint declaration on maritime cooperation outlines a shared vision for maintaining a stable and rules-based maritime order. This includes cooperation in areas such as maritime domain awareness, information sharing, and joint patrols. Both countries are also working together to enhance maritime security in the Indian Ocean, addressing challenges such as piracy, terrorism, and illegal fishing.

• Critical Minerals: The Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) on mining and processing critical and strategic minerals is a significant development, reflecting the growing importance of these minerals for both countries. Critical minerals are essential for a wide range of industries, including renewable energy, electric vehicles, and defense. India is seeking to secure access to critical minerals to support its growing economy and its clean energy transition. Australia is a major producer of critical minerals and is seeking to diversify its export markets. The MoU will facilitate cooperation in exploration, mining, processing, and research and development of critical minerals.

• Cultural Exchange: People-to-people links are an important foundation of the India-Australia relationship. The two countries have a vibrant and growing Indian diaspora in Australia, which contributes significantly to the Australian economy and society. Cultural exchanges, educational programs, and tourism promote greater understanding and appreciation between the two countries.

The '2+2' Dialogue: A Strategic Cornerstone

The elevation of the '2+2' dialogue to the level of Foreign and Defence Ministers represents a pivotal enhancement in the strategic framework between India and Australia. This mechanism, mirroring similar dialogues India maintains with key strategic partners like the United States and Japan, signifies a deeper level of trust and commitment to coordinated action on regional and global security issues.

The '2+2' format allows for a comprehensive and integrated discussion of strategic concerns, bringing together the top diplomatic and defense officials from both nations. This enables a holistic assessment of the geopolitical landscape, the identification of shared threats and opportunities, and the formulation of joint strategies to address them.

The significance of the '2+2' dialogue lies in its ability to transcend traditional bureaucratic silos and foster a more collaborative and proactive approach to foreign policy and defense cooperation. It provides a platform for in-depth exchanges on sensitive issues, facilitating a deeper understanding of each other's perspectives and priorities.

The Mutual Logistics Support Agreement (MLSA): Enhancing Interoperability

The signing of the Mutual Logistics Support Agreement (MLSA) is another important milestone in India-Australia defense cooperation. This agreement allows the armed forces of both countries to use each other's bases for logistics support during joint exercises, humanitarian assistance, and disaster relief operations.

The MLSA enhances interoperability between the two militaries, making it easier for them to operate together in response to regional security challenges. It also reduces the logistical burden on both countries during joint operations, saving time and resources.

The MLSA is a practical demonstration of the growing strategic trust between India and Australia. It reflects a willingness to share resources and capabilities in order to promote regional security and stability.

The Comprehensive Economic Cooperation Agreement (CECA): Unlocking Economic Potential

The renewed commitment to re-engage in talks on a Comprehensive Economic Cooperation Agreement (CECA) is a welcome development, signaling a desire to unlock the full potential of the India-Australia economic partnership.

A CECA would reduce or eliminate tariffs and other trade barriers between the two countries, promoting increased trade and investment. It would also facilitate greater cooperation in areas such as services, technology, and intellectual property.

The potential benefits of a CECA are significant. It would boost economic growth in both countries, create new jobs, and enhance competitiveness. It would also diversify their economies and reduce their dependence on other markets.

The Indo-Pacific Strategy: A Shared Vision

The Indo-Pacific strategy is a central pillar of the India-Australia Comprehensive Strategic Partnership. Both countries recognize the importance of maintaining a stable and rules-based order in the Indo-Pacific region, where freedom of navigation, respect for international law, and peaceful resolution of disputes are paramount.

India and Australia share concerns about China's growing assertiveness in the region, particularly its territorial claims in the South China Sea and its increasing military presence in the Indian Ocean. They are working together to counter these challenges and promote a more balanced and inclusive regional order.

The Indo-Pacific strategy involves a range of initiatives, including increased defense cooperation, joint maritime patrols, and support for regional institutions such as the ASEAN Regional Forum (ARF) and the Indian Ocean Rim Association (IORA).

The Forum for India-Pacific Islands Cooperation (FIPIC): Engaging with the Pacific

India's engagement with the Pacific Island countries through the Forum for India-Pacific Islands Cooperation (FIPIC) is another important aspect of its Indo-Pacific strategy. FIPIC provides a platform for India to engage with 14 Pacific Island countries on issues such as climate change, sustainable development, and economic growth.

Australia also has strong ties with the Pacific Island countries and is working with India to promote development and security in the region. The two countries are collaborating on projects such as climate change adaptation, disaster relief, and maritime security.

The QUAD Security Dialogue: A Coalition of Democracies

The Quadrilateral Security Dialogue (QUAD), comprising India, Australia, Japan, and the United States, is an informal strategic forum that brings together four of the world's leading democracies to discuss issues of common concern in the Indo-Pacific region.

The QUAD is not a military alliance, but it provides a platform for strategic consultations and information sharing. The four countries are working together to promote a rules-based order in the Indo-Pacific, counter terrorism, and enhance maritime security.

The QUAD has been criticized by China, which views it as an attempt to contain its rise. However, the four countries maintain that the QUAD is not directed against any particular country and that its goal is to promote peace and stability in the region.

Organizations Involved: Multilateral Cooperation

India and Australia actively participate in various multilateral organizations and forums, including:

• Indian Ocean Rim Association (IORA): IORA is a regional organization that promotes economic and security cooperation among countries bordering the Indian Ocean. India and Australia are both founding members of IORA and are working together to enhance maritime security, promote trade and investment, and address other regional challenges.

• ASEAN Regional Forum (ARF): The ARF is a multilateral forum that brings together countries from across the Asia-Pacific region to discuss political and security issues. India and Australia are both members of the ARF and are working together to promote dialogue and cooperation on regional security challenges.

• G-20: The G-20 is an intergovernmental forum that brings together the world's leading economies to address global economic and financial issues. India and Australia are both members of the G-20 and are working together to promote sustainable economic growth, financial stability, and international cooperation.

Legal Frameworks: Strengthening Cooperation

Several legal frameworks underpin the India-Australia relationship, facilitating cooperation in various areas:

• Civil Nuclear Cooperation Agreement (2014): This agreement allows Australia to export uranium to India for its civilian nuclear program, under strict safeguards. It strengthens India's energy security and promotes cooperation in the peaceful uses of nuclear energy.

• Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty (MLAT): The MLAT facilitates cooperation between law enforcement agencies in India and Australia in criminal investigations and prosecutions. It provides a framework for sharing information, evidence, and other forms of legal assistance.

• Extradition Treaty: The Extradition Treaty provides a legal basis for the extradition of individuals accused or convicted of crimes between India and Australia. It outlines the procedures and conditions for extradition.

• Social Security Agreement: The Social Security Agreement coordinates social security benefits for individuals who have worked in both India and Australia. It ensures that individuals can receive social security benefits from both countries.

Historical Precedents: Learning from Experience

The India-Australia '2+2' dialogue draws on the experience of similar dialogues that India has established with other strategic partners, such as the United States. The India-US '2+2' dialogue has proven to be a valuable platform for strategic discussions and cooperation on security and foreign policy issues. It provides a model for the India-Australia '2+2' dialogue.

Stakeholder Positions: Diverse Perspectives

Various stakeholders have different perspectives on the India-Australia Comprehensive Strategic Partnership:

• India: India seeks to strengthen its strategic partnership with Australia and expand its influence in the Indo-Pacific region. It views Australia as a key partner in promoting a stable and rules-based regional order.

• Australia: Australia aims to deepen its strategic and economic ties with India and promote a rules-based order in the Indo-Pacific region. It views India as a major power with growing strategic interests.

• China: China views the growing strategic partnership between India and Australia with suspicion and concern. It sees the QUAD security dialogue as an attempt to contain its rise.

Broader Implications: Political, Economic, and Security Dimensions

The India-Australia Comprehensive Strategic Partnership has significant implications for the region and the world:

• Political: It strengthens the political relationship between India and Australia and enhances their ability to coordinate on regional and global issues.

• Diplomatic: It sends a strong signal of cooperation and alignment to other countries in the Indo-Pacific region.

  Advertisement

• Legal: It establishes a legal framework for cooperation in various areas, such as security, trade, and law enforcement.

• Security: It enhances the security of both countries and contributes to regional stability.

• Economic: It promotes increased trade and investment between India and Australia and creates new economic opportunities.

Connections and Context: Ongoing Issues and Future Outlook

The India-Australia Comprehensive Strategic Partnership is connected to several ongoing issues in the Indo-Pacific region, including:

• China's growing influence: The rise of China is a major factor driving closer cooperation between India and Australia.

• Maritime security: Maritime security is a shared concern for both countries, given their reliance on maritime trade routes.

  Advertisement

• The QUAD security dialogue: The QUAD provides a platform for strategic consultations and cooperation on security issues.

• Regional economic integration: India and Australia are both working to promote regional economic integration through initiatives such as the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP).

The strategic partnership between India and Australia is likely to deepen in the coming years, with increased cooperation in areas such as security, trade, and technology. The two countries will likely continue to work together to promote a stable and rules-based order in the Indo-Pacific region.