India And Eurasian Economic Union Indias Potential Free Trade Agreement

In 2020, Russia announced its intention to finalize a Free Trade Agreement (FTA) with India within the framework of the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU). The EAEU, comprising Russia, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Armenia, and Kyrgyzstan, is a regional economic bloc aimed at fostering economic integration. Established through a treaty that came into effect in 2015, the union promotes the free movement of goods, services, capital, and labor among its member states. Russia views an FTA with India as a strategic move to deepen economic ties, diversify its trade partnerships, and expand influence in the rapidly growing Indian market.

Russia’s initiative to negotiate an FTA with India reflects broader geopolitical and economic efforts to strengthen Eurasian regional cooperation amid shifting global trade dynamics. The move garnered attention as India, with its expanding economy and strategic importance, sought to explore new avenues for trade and investment outside traditional Western-led agreements. The negotiations, if successful, could significantly enhance trade relations, facilitate market access, and reshape regional economic alignments.

---

The prospect of an India–Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU) Free Trade Agreement (FTA) emerged in 2020 as a notable development in international trade and regional integration. This initiative signifies a convergence of Russia’s strategic ambitions to expand influence across Eurasia and India’s pursuit of diversifying its trade partners amid global uncertainties. It also underscores the evolving dynamics of regional economic blocs, their external outreach, and the geopolitical implications of such agreements.

This comprehensive analysis explores the background, context, actors, legal frameworks, negotiation processes, and broader implications of this potential FTA, illustrating its significance within the complex tapestry of Indian foreign relations and Eurasian geopolitics.

The Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU): Formation and Objectives

The EAEU was established to mirror the European Union's economic integration model but with a different scope and institutional structure. Its founding treaty, the Treaty on the Eurasian Economic Union, was signed in 2014 and came into force in January 2015. The union aims to create a unified economic space that facilitates free movement of goods, services, capital, and labor among member states, which currently include Russia, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Armenia, and Kyrgyzstan.

The EAEU’s primary objectives are to promote economic stability, enhance regional competitiveness, and foster cooperation among member states. While it promotes economic integration, it also serves as a geopolitical tool for Russia to maintain influence within the post-Soviet space and extend its reach into neighboring regions.

India’s Strategic Engagement with Eurasia

India’s engagement with Eurasian countries has historically been characterized by a mix of diplomacy, trade, and strategic partnerships. While India has longstanding ties with Russia—its traditional partner in defense and strategic cooperation—its relations with other Eurasian states, such as Central Asian nations, have been growing, driven by shared interests in energy, connectivity, and regional stability.

India’s Look East and Act East policies emphasize expanding economic and strategic partnerships with Eurasia to diversify its global engagements. The potential FTA with the EAEU fits into this broader strategy, offering opportunities for increased market access, investment, and geopolitical influence.

Russia’s Geopolitical and Economic Motivations

Russia, as the dominant member of the EAEU, seeks to expand its economic influence beyond its traditional sphere. The country’s efforts to negotiate an FTA with India are driven by multiple motives:

• Economic Diversification: Reduce dependence on Western markets and sanctions by expanding trade with Asia.
• Geopolitical Influence: Strengthen ties with a rising India to counterbalance Western alliances.
• Market Expansion: Gain access to India’s large and growing consumer base.
• Regional Leadership: Position itself as a key facilitator of Eurasian integration and cooperation.

Global Context

The global trade environment post-2020 has been characterized by disruptions caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, US-China trade tensions, and shifting alliances. Many regional blocs have accelerated efforts to negotiate trade agreements to ensure economic resilience. The potential India–EAEU FTA is part of this broader trend towards regionalism and economic diversification.

Russia

As the leading power in the EAEU, Russia is the primary advocate for the FTA with India. It aims to leverage the union’s collective economic weight to attract new trade partners. Russia’s diplomatic efforts include public statements emphasizing the importance of deepening ties with India, a key partner in Eurasian strategies.

India

India’s government has shown interest in exploring FTAs with various regional blocs to boost exports, attract investment, and secure access to critical resources. An FTA with the EAEU would complement existing trade agreements with other countries and regions, such as the ASEAN, Japan, and the European Union (through negotiations). India’s strategic goal is to balance its relationships with Western powers and regional players.

EAEU Institutions

The Eurasian Economic Commission (EEC), the executive body overseeing the union’s policies, plays a crucial role. It formulates trade policies, coordinates economic cooperation, and manages negotiations of external trade agreements. The EEC’s legal and institutional framework provides the basis for negotiations with external partners like India.

Other Member States

While Russia is the dominant player, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Armenia, and Kyrgyzstan also have a stake in the union’s external trade relations. Their positions and interests influence the negotiation process, especially regarding standards, tariffs, and regulatory alignment.

The Treaty on the EAEU

The legal foundation of the union, the Treaty on the Eurasian Economic Union, establishes the principles of economic integration, the functions of the Eurasian Economic Commission, and the rules governing external trade agreements. It mandates that any external trade deal, including an FTA, must be consistent with the treaty’s provisions and ratified by all member states.

The Negotiation Process

Trade negotiations involve diplomatic discussions, treaty drafting, and ratification processes. The EAEU’s approach typically involves multiple rounds of negotiations, technical committees, and consensus among member states. Russia, as the chief negotiator and the largest economy, leads these efforts, with input from other member states.

Precedents and Past Agreements

The EAEU has previously negotiated and signed trade agreements with countries like Vietnam, Singapore, and Iran. These agreements serve as precedents and provide frameworks that could be adapted for an India–EAEU FTA, including provisions on tariffs, standards, and dispute resolution mechanisms.

Free Trade Agreement (FTA)

An FTA reduces or eliminates tariffs, quotas, and other trade barriers between participating countries, encouraging increased trade flows and economic integration. It often includes provisions on intellectual property, standards, investment, and dispute settlement.

EAEU’s Common Market

The EAEU aims to establish a single economic space with harmonized policies, customs procedures, and standards. An FTA with India would potentially integrate India into this common market, subject to negotiations on standards and regulatory alignment.

Customs Union vs. Free Trade Area

The EAEU functions as a Customs Union, where member states have a common external tariff and customs procedures. An FTA with India would be a step towards closer integration but would require adjustments to the existing customs arrangements.

Economic Disparities

Differences in economic size, standards, and competitiveness among EAEU members and India pose challenges. Harmonizing standards, resolving tariff discrepancies, and aligning policies require complex negotiations.

Regulatory and Standards Harmonization

To facilitate seamless trade, both sides need to agree on standards, certification procedures, and technical regulations. Disparities could act as barriers if not addressed effectively.

Political and Strategic Considerations

While economic interests are central, political factors influence negotiations. India's desire to balance Western influence and Russia’s aim to expand Eurasian influence intersect in complex ways.

External Factors

Global uncertainties, including US sanctions, the COVID-19 pandemic, and shifting alliances, impact the negotiation environment. The potential for adding other partners or expanding the scope of the agreement also influences the process.

Political

A successful India–EAEU FTA would deepen Russia–India relations, enhancing strategic cooperation. It could also shift regional power dynamics, emphasizing Eurasian integration and India’s role as a key partner.

Diplomatic

The agreement would signal a new phase of Eurasian-Indian diplomacy, fostering multilateral cooperation and possibly encouraging other countries to join or negotiate similar agreements.

Economic

An FTA would open new markets for Indian exports, especially in sectors like pharmaceuticals, information technology, textiles, and agriculture. It could also attract Eurasian investment into India.

Security and Geopolitics

Economic integration could translate into closer strategic ties, impacting regional security architectures, especially concerning China, the US, and other regional powers.

Challenges and Risks

Economic dependence, standardization hurdles, and geopolitical tensions could pose risks. Ensuring equitable benefits among all parties and managing domestic opposition are critical.

Russia’s Eurasian Integration Strategy

Russia’s push for integration through the EAEU aligns with its broader ambition to create a Eurasian economic and political bloc that counters Western influence. Engaging India, a rising global power, enhances this vision, potentially creating a counterbalance to Western-led trade alliances.

India’s ‘Act East’ and Global Outreach

India’s foreign policy emphasizes expanding economic ties with Asia and Eurasia, diversifying away from Western-centric agreements. An FTA with the EAEU complements its efforts to bolster regional connectivity, energy cooperation, and strategic partnerships.

Post-2020 Global Shift Toward Regionalism

The pandemic underscored vulnerabilities in global supply chains, prompting countries and blocs to seek regional agreements. The India–EAEU FTA reflects this trend, aiming for resilient and diversified trade networks.

Possibility of an FTA

While negotiations are complex and protracted, the political will expressed by both sides suggests that an agreement could be reached in the coming years, especially as both seek to capitalize on regional and global opportunities.

Expansion and Deepening of Ties

Beyond a simple FTA, there is potential for deeper economic integration, including investments, joint infrastructure projects, and cooperation in technology and innovation.

Broader Regional Impact

The success of India–EAEU negotiations might inspire similar agreements with other regional blocs, fostering a multipolar Eurasian trade landscape that enhances India’s global economic role.

---

Connecting Broader Issues in Indian Foreign Relations

India’s pursuit of FTAs with Eurasian countries exemplifies its strategic balancing act—seeking economic growth, geopolitical influence, and regional stability. It aligns with its broader foreign policy objectives of diversifying trade, securing strategic partnerships, and asserting itself as a regional power capable of shaping Eurasian economic architectures.

Russia’s efforts to forge closer ties with India within the EAEU framework also reflect its desire to reassert influence in Eurasia and counterbalance Western sanctions and diplomatic pressures. The India–EAEU FTA could serve as a catalyst for broader regional cooperation, influencing the geopolitical landscape of Asia and Eurasia.

In the context of global shifts toward regionalism and economic resilience, this potential agreement underscores India’s proactive approach to shaping its economic future while navigating complex geopolitical terrains. It also illuminates the evolving nature of regional trade agreements, their strategic significance, and the importance of multilateral diplomacy in the 21st century.

This development must be viewed within the larger framework of India’s comprehensive foreign policy strategy—balancing relations with the United States, China, Russia, and regional partners—aimed at securing economic growth, strategic autonomy, and regional stability amid an increasingly multipolar world.