India Afghanistan Relations Via Chabahar Port And Connectivity Initiatives 2019

Afghanistan commenced exports to India through the Chabahar port in 2019, marking a significant step in diversifying its trade routes and reducing reliance on Pakistan. The Chabahar port, developed in Iran with Indian investment, provides an alternative access point to global markets for Afghanistan, bypassing traditional routes through Pakistan. Goods arriving at Chabahar can be transported to the Afghan border and distributed within Afghanistan via the Zaranj-Delaram highway, which was constructed by India. This initiative not only benefits Afghanistan but also allows India to potentially export iron ore from the Hajigak mines in central Afghanistan. The Chabahar port project is intended to enhance regional integration for Afghanistan and diminish Pakistan's regional influence.

In addition to the Chabahar port, other initiatives are underway to improve connectivity between India and Afghanistan. These include the India-Afghanistan Air Corridor, established to reduce reliance on Karachi port by providing subsidized air cargo, and the Afghanistan-Pakistan Transit Trade Agreement (APTTA), which allows Afghan goods to transit through the Wagah border to India, and in return, Afghanistan allows Pakistan transit access to Central Asian Republics. The International North-South Transport Corridor (INSTC) is also poised to boost connectivity to Afghanistan via Chabahar to Zaranj and Delaram, despite Afghanistan not being a direct member. India and Russia have signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) to expedite INSTC implementation, with Russian Railways Logistics Joint Stock Company (RZD) and Container Corporation of India (CONCOR) collaborating on logistics services.

The Significance of Chabahar Port and Connectivity Initiatives in India-Afghanistan Relations

The year 2019 witnessed a pivotal moment in India-Afghanistan relations with the commencement of Afghan exports to India via the Chabahar port. This event underscored the deepening strategic and economic partnership between the two nations and highlighted the ongoing efforts to enhance regional connectivity, reduce Afghanistan's dependence on Pakistan, and foster greater economic integration in the region. The Chabahar port project, along with other connectivity initiatives such as the India-Afghanistan Air Corridor and the International North-South Transport Corridor (INSTC), represents a multifaceted approach to addressing Afghanistan's unique challenges as a landlocked country and promoting stability and prosperity in the broader South Asian region.

Afghanistan's Landlocked Predicament and the Quest for Alternative Trade Routes

Afghanistan's geographical location as a landlocked country has historically posed significant challenges to its economic development and integration with the global economy. Surrounded by countries with varying degrees of political stability and infrastructure development, Afghanistan has traditionally relied on Pakistan as its primary transit route for international trade. However, this dependence has been fraught with difficulties, including political tensions, security concerns, and disruptions to trade flows. The relationship between Afghanistan and Pakistan has been marked by periods of cooperation and conflict, with disagreements over border issues, cross-border terrorism, and the role of various actors in the Afghan conflict. As a result, Afghanistan has sought to diversify its trade routes and reduce its reliance on Pakistan, recognizing that greater economic independence is crucial for its long-term stability and sovereignty.

The need for alternative trade routes became even more pressing in the wake of the U.S.-led invasion of Afghanistan in 2001 and the subsequent efforts to rebuild the country's economy and infrastructure. With international aid flowing into Afghanistan and increased demand for goods and services, the limitations of the existing transit infrastructure became apparent. The Karachi port in Pakistan, which had traditionally served as the main gateway for Afghan trade, faced congestion and delays, while the security situation along the transit routes remained precarious. This prompted Afghanistan to explore alternative options for accessing global markets, including the development of new ports and transport corridors.

Chabahar Port: A Strategic Lifeline for Afghanistan

The Chabahar port project emerged as a viable solution to Afghanistan's transit challenges, offering a direct sea route to India and access to global markets without relying on Pakistani territory. Located in southeastern Iran, the Chabahar port is strategically positioned on the Gulf of Oman, providing access to the Indian Ocean and beyond. The port's development has been a collaborative effort between India, Iran, and Afghanistan, with India playing a key role in providing financial and technical assistance.

India's interest in the Chabahar port stems from its strategic objectives in the region, including enhancing connectivity with Central Asia, countering Pakistan's influence, and promoting economic development in Afghanistan. By investing in the Chabahar port, India aims to create a viable alternative to the traditional trade routes through Pakistan, which have been subject to disruptions and political manipulation. The port also provides India with access to the resource-rich countries of Central Asia, bypassing Pakistan and enhancing its economic and strategic reach in the region.

The development of the Chabahar port has involved the construction of new berths, container terminals, and other infrastructure facilities, as well as the dredging of the harbor to accommodate larger vessels. India has committed to investing billions of dollars in the project, recognizing its potential to transform regional trade and connectivity. The port is expected to handle a significant volume of cargo, including goods destined for Afghanistan, India, and Central Asia.

The Zaranj-Delaram Highway: Connecting Chabahar to Afghanistan's Interior

To facilitate the transport of goods from Chabahar port into Afghanistan, India has also invested in the construction of the Zaranj-Delaram highway. This 218-kilometer highway connects Zaranj, a town near the Iranian border, to Delaram, a major road junction in western Afghanistan. The highway provides a crucial link between the Chabahar port and the Afghan interior, enabling the efficient movement of goods and people.

The construction of the Zaranj-Delaram highway was a challenging undertaking, given the difficult terrain and security situation in the region. However, India persevered with the project, recognizing its importance for Afghanistan's economic development and connectivity. The highway has significantly reduced travel times and transportation costs, facilitating trade and commerce within Afghanistan. It has also improved access to remote areas, enabling the delivery of essential services and humanitarian aid.

The Zaranj-Delaram highway is not only a vital transportation link but also a symbol of India's commitment to Afghanistan's development. The project has provided employment opportunities for local communities and has contributed to the overall improvement of infrastructure in the region. It has also strengthened the bond between India and Afghanistan, demonstrating India's willingness to support Afghanistan's long-term stability and prosperity.

The India-Afghanistan Air Corridor: Bypassing Land Routes for High-Value Goods

In addition to the Chabahar port and the Zaranj-Delaram highway, India and Afghanistan have also established an air corridor to facilitate trade and reduce reliance on land routes through Pakistan. The India-Afghanistan Air Corridor provides subsidized air cargo services between major cities in India and Afghanistan, enabling the faster and more reliable transport of high-value goods.

The air corridor has been particularly beneficial for the trade of perishable goods, such as fruits and vegetables, which require rapid transportation to maintain their quality. It has also facilitated the trade of handicrafts, textiles, and other products that are not easily transported by land. The air corridor has significantly reduced transit times and transportation costs, making it easier for Afghan businesses to access Indian markets and vice versa.

The establishment of the India-Afghanistan Air Corridor reflects the growing economic ties between the two countries and their commitment to promoting trade and investment. The air corridor has not only boosted bilateral trade but has also enhanced people-to-people connections, fostering greater understanding and cooperation between the two nations.

The Afghanistan-Pakistan Transit Trade Agreement (APTTA): A Troubled Partnership

While India and Afghanistan have been working to enhance connectivity through alternative routes, the Afghanistan-Pakistan Transit Trade Agreement (APTTA) remains an important framework for facilitating trade between the two countries. Signed in 2010, APTTA allows Afghan goods to transit through Pakistan to India (Wagah border), and vice versa, allowing Pakistani goods transit to Central Asian Republics through Afghanistan.

The APTTA was intended to promote trade and economic cooperation between Afghanistan and Pakistan, but its implementation has been hampered by political tensions and security concerns. The agreement has been subject to frequent disruptions and delays, with both sides accusing each other of violating its provisions. Pakistan has often cited security concerns as a reason for restricting the movement of goods across its territory, while Afghanistan has accused Pakistan of using trade as a political tool.

Despite the challenges, the APTTA remains an important mechanism for facilitating trade between Afghanistan and Pakistan. The agreement provides a legal framework for transit trade and has the potential to significantly boost economic activity in the region. However, its effectiveness depends on the willingness of both sides to address the underlying political and security issues that have undermined its implementation.

The International North-South Transport Corridor (INSTC): A Broader Vision for Regional Connectivity

The International North-South Transport Corridor (INSTC) is a multi-modal transport corridor linking India, Iran, Russia, and other countries in Central Asia and Europe. The INSTC aims to provide a shorter and more cost-effective trade route between India and Russia/Europe, bypassing traditional routes through the Suez Canal. Chabahar port serves as a key entry point for INSTC into Afghanistan and Central Asia.

The INSTC has the potential to significantly boost regional trade and connectivity, reducing transit times and transportation costs. The corridor is expected to facilitate the movement of goods between India, Iran, Russia, and other countries in the region, promoting economic growth and integration. The INSTC is also strategically important, as it provides an alternative trade route that bypasses Pakistan and enhances India's access to Central Asia.

India has been actively promoting the INSTC, working with its partners to develop the necessary infrastructure and streamline customs procedures. The completion of the Chabahar port is a crucial step in realizing the full potential of the INSTC, as it provides a vital link between the maritime and land-based components of the corridor. The INSTC is not only an economic project but also a symbol of regional cooperation and integration, bringing together countries with diverse interests and backgrounds.

Key Actors and Their Roles

The development of the Chabahar port and other connectivity initiatives has involved a diverse range of actors, each with its own interests and objectives. Some of the key actors include:

• Afghanistan: As a landlocked country seeking to diversify its trade routes and reduce dependence on Pakistan, Afghanistan has been a strong advocate for the Chabahar port project and other connectivity initiatives. The Afghan government has worked closely with India and Iran to develop the necessary infrastructure and facilitate trade. Afghanistan sees the Chabahar port as a vital lifeline for its economy and a symbol of its growing partnership with India.

• India: India has been the driving force behind the Chabahar port project, providing financial and technical assistance and working with Iran and Afghanistan to develop the necessary infrastructure. India sees the Chabahar port as a strategic asset, enhancing its connectivity with Central Asia, countering Pakistan's influence, and promoting economic development in Afghanistan. India is committed to supporting Afghanistan's long-term stability and prosperity and sees the Chabahar port as a key component of its strategy.

• Iran: As the host country of the Chabahar port, Iran has played a crucial role in facilitating trade between India and Afghanistan. Iran sees the Chabahar port as an opportunity to enhance its regional influence, boost its economy, and strengthen its ties with India and Afghanistan. Iran has worked closely with India to develop the port and has provided the necessary security and logistical support.

• Pakistan: Pakistan has viewed the Chabahar port project with suspicion, seeing it as an attempt by India to undermine its regional influence and bypass its territory. Pakistan has expressed concerns about the security implications of the Chabahar port and has accused India of using it to support terrorist activities in Balochistan. However, Pakistan has also recognized the potential benefits of regional connectivity and has expressed willingness to participate in projects that promote trade and economic cooperation.

• Russia: Russia is a key partner in the INSTC, working with India and Iran to develop the corridor and facilitate trade between India and Russia/Europe. Russia sees the INSTC as an opportunity to enhance its economic and strategic reach in the region and to counter the influence of the United States and other Western powers. Russia has been actively promoting the INSTC and has invested in the necessary infrastructure.

Organizations Involved

Several organizations have been involved in the development and implementation of the Chabahar port and other connectivity initiatives. These include:

• Container Corporation of India (CONCOR): CONCOR is an Indian public sector undertaking that provides logistics services on the INSTC. CONCOR facilitates the transportation of goods within India and internationally, playing a crucial role in ensuring the smooth flow of trade along the corridor.

• Russian Railways Logistics Joint Stock Company (RZD): RZD is a Russian logistics company that provides logistics services on the INSTC. RZD facilitates the transportation of goods within Russia and internationally, working closely with CONCOR to ensure the efficient movement of cargo along the corridor.

Historical Precedents

India's engagement with Afghanistan has a long and complex history, dating back centuries. India has traditionally maintained close ties with Afghanistan, providing development assistance, educational opportunities, and security support. India's support for the Northern Alliance in Afghanistan in the 1990s helped counter the Taliban regime and establish closer ties with the Afghan government. This demonstrates India's long-standing commitment to supporting a stable and independent Afghanistan.

Stakeholder Positions

The various stakeholders involved in the Chabahar port and other connectivity initiatives have different positions and interests.

• India: India is committed to supporting Afghanistan's economic development and regional integration. India's underlying interests include enhancing regional connectivity, accessing Central Asian markets, and countering Pakistan's influence. India has taken actions such as investing in Chabahar port, constructing infrastructure projects, and providing development assistance.

• Afghanistan: Afghanistan is seeking to diversify trade routes and reduce dependence on Pakistan. Afghanistan's underlying interests include enhancing economic independence, attracting foreign investment, and improving regional connectivity. Afghanistan has engaged with India on Chabahar port development and has participated in regional connectivity initiatives.

• Pakistan: Pakistan wants to be the primary trade route for Afghanistan and Central Asia. Pakistan's underlying interests include maintaining regional influence, securing transit fees, and preventing India from gaining a strategic foothold in the region. Pakistan has negotiated transit agreements with Afghanistan, but relations are often strained due to political and security issues.

Broader Implications

The development of the Chabahar port and other connectivity initiatives has broader implications for the region.

• Political: The projects strengthen India-Afghanistan relations and reduce Afghanistan's dependence on Pakistan, shifting regional power dynamics.

• Diplomatic: The projects enhance India's diplomatic influence in Afghanistan and Central Asia, fostering closer ties with regional partners.

  Advertisement

• Security: The projects contribute to regional stability by promoting economic development and reducing reliance on volatile transit routes.

• Economic: The projects boost trade between India and Afghanistan, creating economic opportunities and fostering regional integration.

Connections Context

The Chabahar port and other connectivity initiatives are related to several ongoing issues in the region.

• Geopolitical competition: The projects are part of a broader geopolitical competition between India and Pakistan for influence in Afghanistan and Central Asia.

• The future of Afghanistan: The success of the projects depends on the future stability and security of Afghanistan.

• Regional connectivity: The projects are part of a broader effort to enhance regional connectivity and promote trade and economic cooperation.

  Advertisement

• India-Pakistan relations: The projects are affected by the ongoing tensions between India and Pakistan.

The development of the Chabahar port and other connectivity initiatives represents a significant step forward in India-Afghanistan relations and regional integration. These projects have the potential to transform the economic landscape of the region, promoting trade, investment, and development. However, the success of these initiatives depends on the continued commitment of all stakeholders and the resolution of the underlying political and security challenges. The future stability of Afghanistan will be a key factor in determining the long-term success of these projects.