Expanded ASEAN Maritime Forum EAMF

The 5th Expanded ASEAN Maritime Forum (EAMF) convened in Jakarta, Indonesia, bringing together the ten Southeast Asian countries along with Australia, China, India, Japan, New Zealand, South Korea, Russia, and the United States. Established in 2012 during the ASEAN High Conference in Manila, Philippines, the EAMF serves as a crucial platform for addressing pressing maritime issues among its members, including territorial disputes, piracy, and the establishment of comprehensive maritime regulations.

Prior to the EAMF's inception, the Asia Maritime Organization for Security and Cooperation (AMOSC) was the primary body responsible for these discussions, but it proved to be largely ineffective, highlighting the need for a more robust and inclusive forum. The EAMF aims to foster enhanced cooperation and collaboration among its diverse participants to ensure maritime security and stability in the region.

The Expanded ASEAN Maritime Forum: Navigating the Complexities of Maritime Security in Southeast Asia

The convening of the 5th Expanded ASEAN Maritime Forum (EAMF) in Jakarta, Indonesia, marked another chapter in the ongoing efforts to address the multifaceted challenges of maritime security in the Southeast Asian region. This forum, established in 2012, represents a significant evolution in regional cooperation, bringing together not only the ten member states of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) but also eight key dialogue partners: Australia, China, India, Japan, New Zealand, South Korea, Russia, and the United States. The EAMF's mandate encompasses a broad spectrum of maritime issues, ranging from territorial disputes and piracy to the development of comprehensive maritime regulations, all of which are critical to maintaining stability and promoting economic prosperity in this vital region.

Genesis of the EAMF: Addressing the Shortcomings of AMOSC

The creation of the EAMF was, in part, a response to the perceived inadequacies of its predecessor, the Asia Maritime Organization for Security and Cooperation (AMOSC). While details regarding the precise structure, powers, and limitations of AMOSC are scarce in the provided information, its failure to effectively address the growing maritime security concerns in the region became increasingly apparent. The ASEAN member states, recognizing the need for a more inclusive and action-oriented platform, spearheaded the establishment of the EAMF during the ASEAN High Conference in Manila in 2012. This new forum was designed to overcome the limitations of AMOSC by fostering greater dialogue, information sharing, and joint initiatives among a wider range of stakeholders, including major powers with significant maritime interests in the region.

ASEAN's Central Role: Fostering Regional Cooperation

At the heart of the EAMF lies ASEAN, a regional intergovernmental organization that has played a pivotal role in promoting cooperation and integration among its ten member states: Brunei, Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Myanmar, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, and Vietnam. Established in 1967, ASEAN's primary objectives include accelerating economic growth, promoting social progress, and fostering peace and stability in the region. Over the years, ASEAN has evolved into a significant force in international relations, serving as a platform for dialogue and cooperation on a wide range of issues, including political, security, economic, and socio-cultural matters.

ASEAN's convening power and consensus-based decision-making processes are central to the functioning of the EAMF. The organization provides the framework for dialogue, sets the agenda, and facilitates negotiations among its member states and external partners. However, ASEAN's limitations, particularly its reliance on member states' cooperation and its limited enforcement mechanisms, also influence the EAMF's effectiveness. The success of the forum ultimately depends on the willingness of participating nations to engage in constructive dialogue, compromise on their positions, and implement agreed-upon measures.

The Expanding Circle: Dialogue Partners and Their Interests

The inclusion of eight dialogue partners in the EAMF reflects the recognition that maritime security in Southeast Asia is not solely a regional concern but has far-reaching implications for global trade, security, and stability. Each of these countries brings its own unique perspectives, interests, and capabilities to the forum.

• Australia: As a key strategic partner in the Indo-Pacific region, Australia has a strong interest in maintaining maritime security and freedom of navigation in Southeast Asia. Australia's involvement in the EAMF underscores its commitment to regional stability and its willingness to work with ASEAN and other partners to address shared challenges.

• China: China's participation in the EAMF is particularly significant given its status as a major economic and military power with substantial maritime interests in the South China Sea. China's assertive actions in the South China Sea, including its expansive territorial claims and its construction of artificial islands, have raised concerns among other claimant states and the international community. China's engagement in the EAMF provides an opportunity for dialogue and confidence-building measures, but its commitment to resolving disputes peacefully and adhering to international law remains a key question.

• India: India's involvement in the EAMF reflects its growing strategic interests in Southeast Asia and the Indian Ocean Region. India's "Act East" policy, which aims to strengthen its ties with ASEAN member states, highlights the importance of maritime security cooperation in the region. India's participation in joint naval exercises with ASEAN countries and its advocacy for freedom of navigation demonstrate its commitment to maintaining a stable and secure maritime environment.

  Advertisement

• Japan: As a major economic power with strong maritime interests and security concerns in the region, Japan has a vested interest in ensuring the safety and security of sea lanes in Southeast Asia. Japan's dependence on maritime trade makes it particularly vulnerable to disruptions caused by piracy, terrorism, or territorial disputes. Japan's participation in the EAMF underscores its commitment to working with ASEAN and other partners to address these challenges.

• New Zealand: New Zealand's involvement in the EAMF reflects its commitment to regional stability and its interest in promoting maritime security in the Pacific and Southeast Asian regions. New Zealand's contributions to maritime security cooperation include providing training and capacity building assistance to ASEAN member states.

• South Korea: As a key economic and strategic player in East Asia, South Korea has a strong interest in maintaining maritime security and freedom of navigation in Southeast Asia. South Korea's economic ties with ASEAN member states and its dependence on maritime trade make it particularly vulnerable to disruptions caused by maritime security threats.

• Russia: Russia's participation in the EAMF reflects its growing interest in the Asia-Pacific region and its desire to play a greater role in regional security affairs. Russia's involvement in the forum provides an opportunity for dialogue and cooperation with ASEAN and other partners on maritime security issues.

• United States: The United States, as a major global power with significant security interests in the Indo-Pacific region, has a strong interest in maintaining maritime security and freedom of navigation in Southeast Asia. The United States' commitment to the region is demonstrated through its participation in the EAMF, its conduct of freedom of navigation operations, and its strengthening of alliances with regional partners.

Navigating the Murky Waters: Key Maritime Security Challenges

The EAMF's agenda is driven by a range of pressing maritime security challenges that threaten stability and prosperity in Southeast Asia. These challenges include:

• Territorial Disputes: The South China Sea is a hotbed of overlapping territorial claims involving multiple ASEAN member states (Brunei, Malaysia, the Philippines, and Vietnam) and China. These disputes center on the ownership of islands, reefs, and other maritime features, as well as the delineation of maritime boundaries. China's expansive claims, based on its "nine-dash line," have been rejected by other claimant states and the international community. The disputes have led to tensions, confrontations, and concerns about the potential for escalation. The EAMF provides a platform for dialogue and negotiation, but resolving these complex disputes requires a sustained commitment to peaceful means and adherence to international law.

• Piracy: Piracy remains a persistent threat to maritime security in Southeast Asia, particularly in the Malacca and Singapore Straits, which are vital shipping lanes for global trade. Acts of piracy not only disrupt trade and endanger seafarers but also undermine maritime security and stability in the region. Combating piracy requires coordinated efforts among ASEAN member states, as well as cooperation with international partners, to enhance maritime domain awareness, strengthen law enforcement capabilities, and promote information sharing.

• Maritime Regulations: The absence of clear and consistent maritime regulations can create uncertainty and increase the risk of accidents, illegal fishing, and other illicit activities at sea. The EAMF provides an opportunity for participating nations to develop common standards and practices for maritime governance, promoting adherence to international law and ensuring the sustainable use of marine resources.

The Guiding Light: UNCLOS and International Law

The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), adopted in 1982, serves as the overarching legal framework for all activities in the oceans and seas. UNCLOS establishes the rights and responsibilities of states with regard to maritime zones, navigation, resource management, and dispute resolution. The convention defines various maritime zones, including territorial waters, exclusive economic zones (EEZs), and the high seas, and sets out the rules for delimiting maritime boundaries between states.

UNCLOS plays a critical role in resolving territorial disputes and regulating maritime activities in the Southeast Asian region. The convention provides the legal basis for determining the validity of territorial claims, delimiting maritime boundaries, and ensuring freedom of navigation. However, the interpretation and application of UNCLOS are often contested, particularly in the context of the South China Sea disputes. China, for example, has rejected the 2016 ruling by the Permanent Court of Arbitration, which found that its "nine-dash line" claim had no legal basis under UNCLOS.

Processes and Procedures: The Art of Diplomatic Dialogue

The EAMF relies heavily on diplomatic dialogue as the primary means of addressing maritime security challenges. Diplomatic dialogue involves formal and informal discussions between states to exchange views, negotiate agreements, and build consensus on issues of mutual concern. The normal protocol for diplomatic dialogue includes the presentation of positions, the identification of common ground, and the development of mutually acceptable solutions.

The EAMF serves as a crucial platform for diplomatic dialogue on maritime security issues in Southeast Asia. The forum provides an opportunity for participating nations to engage in open and frank discussions, share information, and explore potential areas of cooperation. However, the effectiveness of diplomatic dialogue depends on the willingness of participating nations to engage in good faith, compromise on their positions, and adhere to agreed-upon principles.

Historical Echoes: Lessons from the South China Sea

The ongoing South China Sea disputes serve as a stark reminder of the challenges of managing maritime security in the region. The disputes have a long and complex history, with roots in competing territorial claims, historical grievances, and strategic rivalries. Over the years, the disputes have led to tensions, confrontations, and concerns about the potential for escalation.

The South China Sea disputes highlight the need for effective dialogue and cooperation mechanisms, such as the EAMF, to manage and resolve maritime disputes peacefully. The disputes also underscore the importance of adhering to international law, respecting the rights of other states, and avoiding unilateral actions that could undermine regional stability.

Stakeholder Positions: A Tapestry of Interests

The EAMF brings together a diverse range of stakeholders, each with its own unique interests and perspectives on maritime security in Southeast Asia. Understanding the positions of these stakeholders is essential for navigating the complexities of the region and promoting effective cooperation.

• ASEAN Member States: ASEAN member states share a common interest in promoting regional stability, economic integration, and the peaceful resolution of disputes. However, their individual interests and priorities may vary depending on their geographic location, economic development, and political orientation. Some ASEAN member states, such as the Philippines and Vietnam, are directly involved in territorial disputes with China in the South China Sea, while others, such as Indonesia and Singapore, have a greater focus on combating piracy and promoting maritime trade.

• China: China's official position is that it has indisputable sovereignty over the disputed territories in the South China Sea. China's underlying interests include securing access to resources, maintaining strategic influence in the region, and protecting its maritime interests. China has taken a number of actions to assert its claims, including constructing artificial islands, deploying military assets, and conducting naval exercises.

• India: India's official position is that it supports freedom of navigation, the peaceful resolution of disputes, and adherence to international law. India's underlying interests include ensuring access to sea lanes for trade, promoting regional stability, and countering China's growing influence in the Indian Ocean Region. India has taken a number of actions to promote its interests, including participating in the EAMF, conducting joint naval exercises with ASEAN member states, and strengthening bilateral relations with countries in the region.

• United States: The United States' official position is that it supports freedom of navigation, the peaceful resolution of disputes, and adherence to international law. The United States' underlying interests include maintaining its strategic presence in the region, countering China's influence, and protecting its economic and security interests. The United States has taken a number of actions to promote its interests, including participating in the EAMF, conducting freedom of navigation operations, and strengthening alliances with regional partners.

Broader Implications: Ripples Across the Region

The EAMF has a range of broader implications for political, diplomatic, legal, security, and economic dynamics in the Southeast Asian region.

• Political: The EAMF can contribute to building trust and confidence among participating nations, reducing the risk of conflict and promoting regional stability. The forum provides a platform for dialogue and negotiation, allowing states to address their concerns and find common ground.

  Advertisement

• Diplomatic: The EAMF fosters better understanding and cooperation among stakeholders by providing a venue for diplomatic engagement and negotiation. The forum allows states to exchange views, build relationships, and develop joint initiatives.

• Legal: Discussions on maritime regulations within the EAMF can lead to the development of common standards and practices, promoting adherence to international law. The forum can help states to clarify their rights and responsibilities under UNCLOS and other relevant legal instruments.

• Security: Enhanced cooperation on maritime security through the EAMF can help combat piracy, terrorism, and other threats, ensuring the safety and security of sea lanes. The forum can facilitate information sharing, joint patrols, and capacity building activities.

• Economic: Improved maritime security, facilitated by the EAMF, can promote trade and investment, fostering economic growth and prosperity in the region. The forum can help to ensure the smooth flow of goods and services through vital shipping lanes.

Connections and Context: A Web of Interrelated Issues

The EAMF operates within a complex web of interrelated issues that shape the maritime security landscape in Southeast Asia. These issues include:

• South China Sea Disputes: As previously discussed, the South China Sea disputes are a major source of tension and instability in the region. The disputes have implications for freedom of navigation, resource management, and regional security.

  Advertisement

• Increasing Chinese Assertiveness: China's growing economic and military power has led to increased assertiveness in the region, particularly in the South China Sea. China's actions have raised concerns among other claimant states and the international community.

• US-China Strategic Competition: The United States and China are engaged in a strategic competition for influence in the Indo-Pacific region. This competition has implications for maritime security, trade, and regional alliances.

• India's Act East Policy: India's "Act East" policy aims to strengthen its ties with ASEAN member states. This policy has implications for maritime security cooperation, trade, and investment.

• Regional Efforts to Combat Piracy and Maritime Terrorism: ASEAN member states have been working together to combat piracy and maritime terrorism in the region. These efforts include joint patrols, information sharing, and capacity building activities.

Historical Connections: Echoes of the Past

The EAMF is rooted in a history of regional cooperation and conflict in Southeast Asia. Key historical connections include:

• The Creation of ASEAN in 1967: The creation of ASEAN marked a significant step towards regional integration and cooperation. ASEAN has played a key role in promoting peace and stability in the region.

  Advertisement

• The Adoption of the Treaty of Amity and Cooperation in Southeast Asia (TAC): The TAC, adopted in 1976, sets out the principles for peaceful relations among ASEAN member states. The TAC emphasizes the importance of non-interference, mutual respect, and the peaceful resolution of disputes.

• Past Incidents of Maritime Disputes and Confrontations in the Region: The history of Southeast Asia is marked by numerous incidents of maritime disputes and confrontations. These incidents highlight the need for effective mechanisms to manage and resolve disputes peacefully.

Future Outlook: Charting a Course for Cooperation

The EAMF is likely to continue serving as a key platform for dialogue and cooperation on maritime security issues in the ASEAN region. Future developments may include:

• Enhanced Cooperation on Combating Piracy: The EAMF could facilitate greater cooperation on information sharing, joint patrols, and capacity building to combat piracy in the region.

• Development of Common Maritime Regulations: The EAMF could promote the development of common standards and practices for maritime governance, ensuring the sustainable use of marine resources and promoting adherence to international law.

• Promoting Peaceful Resolution of Disputes: The EAMF could serve as a forum for dialogue and negotiation to promote the peaceful resolution of territorial disputes in the South China Sea.

  Advertisement

The effectiveness of the EAMF will depend on the willingness of participating nations to engage in constructive dialogue and implement agreed-upon measures. The forum's success will also depend on the ability of ASEAN to maintain its central role in promoting regional cooperation and integration.