The investment world is complex, filled with various theories and models attempting to explain the nuances of asset pricing. Among these theories, the Fama and French Three Factor Model stands out as a significant advancement over older frameworks, particularly the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM). Developed in the early 1990s by Nobel laureates Eugene Fama and Kenneth French, this model incorporates additional factors that have been shown to affect stock returns.
What is the Fama and French Three Factor Model?
The Fama and French Three Factor Model is an asset pricing model that expands on the traditional CAPM by adding two additional risk factors: size and value. While CAPM primarily considers the market risk as represented by the market portfolio, the Fama French Model acknowledges the tendency for smaller companies (small-cap) and value stocks (characterized by a high book-to-market ratio) to outperform larger companies and growth-oriented stocks, respectively.
This adaptation allows for a more refined evaluation of expected returns, especially for portfolio managers who invest heavily in small-cap or value stocks.
The Three Factors Explained
The model identifies three specific factors that contribute to stock returns:
-
Market Risk (RM - RF): This is the excess return of the market portfolio above the risk-free rate. In other words, it measures how much more return an investor expects from investing in the market compared to investing in a risk-free asset such as government bonds.
-
Size Risk (SMB): This factor stands for "Small Minus Big." It represents the additional return that investors can expect from investing in small-cap stocks over large-cap stocks. Historically, portfolios that focused on small-cap companies have provided higher returns than those invested in larger firms.
-
Value Risk (HML): This stands for "High Minus Low.” It refers to the investment return that can be gleaned from value stocks over growth stocks. Value stocks are those that are undervalued in the market, typically with higher book-to-market ratios, while growth stocks are anticipated to grow earnings at an above-average rate.
The Model's Formula
The mathematical representation of the Fama and French Three Factor Model is:
[ R_{it} - R_{ft} = \alpha_{it} + \beta_1 (R_{Mt} - R_{ft}) + \beta_2 SMB_t + \beta_3 HML_t + \epsilon_{it} ]
Where: - ( R_{it} ) = Total return of stock or portfolio i at time t - ( R_{ft} ) = Risk-free rate of return at time t - ( R_{Mt} ) = Total market portfolio return at time t - ( SMB_t ) = Size premium (Small Minus Big) - ( HML_t ) = Value premium (High Minus Low) - ( \alpha_{it} ) = Intercept or "alpha," representing the stock's performance relative to expectations - ( \beta_1, \beta_2, \beta_3 ) = Factor coefficients reflecting sensitivity to each factor
Implications for Investors
The Fama and French Three Factor Model emphasizes the importance of understanding the inherent risks associated with different types of investments. For investors, it highlights that to achieve higher expected returns, one must be willing to endure extra volatility and possible underperformance in the short term, particularly for small-cap and value stocks.
Long-term investors, those with a horizon of 15 years or more, might find this model particularly useful. The research conducted by Fama and French demonstrated that, over extended periods, portfolios constructed based on the principles of the model could explain up to 95% of returns based on their exposure to market, size, and value factors.
The Expansion: Fama and French’s Five Factor Model
In light of ongoing research and market behavior, Fama and French have expanded their model. They introduced the Five Factor Model, which adds two additional factors: Profitability (the performance metric based on future earnings) and Investment (measured by the strategic allocation of resources by companies).
The Two New Factors:
-
Profitability: This factor suggests companies that are able to report higher future earnings tend to yield higher returns in the stock market.
-
Investment: This presents the idea that firms emphasizing growth projects may experience short-term losses in the stock market.
These enhancements provide investors with even more nuanced insights into the dynamics of stock returns.
Conclusion
The Fama and French Three Factor Model represents a milestone in asset pricing theory, offering a more comprehensive framework than its predecessor, CAPM. By integrating size and value factors into stock return assessments, the model provides investors with tools to better gauge the risks and returns associated with their investment decisions.
For those interested in building a portfolio aligned with their investment goals, understanding this model can offer strategic insights into the expected performance of their choices in the context of market dynamics. As the model continues to evolve, it remains a critical part of the financial toolkit for both academics and practitioners alike.